Right To Die With Dignity - Passive Euthanasia Permissible With Guidelines - Says SC

Patient at hospital

The Supreme Court judgment on Friday, allowing a person suffering from terminal illness to refuse medical treatment to avoid "protracted physical suffering" drove a wedge between the scientific and religious domains. The living will is defined as the person's right to issue a pre directive where in which he or she allows the withdrawal of life support or discontinuation of medicine if a situation arises in future of person being in a terminally ill state.

The CJI, while reading out the judgment, said that though there were four separate opinions of the bench but all the judges were unanimous that the "living will" should be permitted since a person can not be allowed to continue suffering in a comatose state when he or she doesn't wish to live. "Following the Supreme Court ruling, the Centre will now have to frame guidelines on the matters around the issue, like who can carry out the process, what is the role of caregivers and such", says Jha.

"In India, you must guard against people terminating the life of another person for properties and other things".

Her plight prompted the Supreme Court to decide in 2011 that life support can be removed for some terminally ill patients in certain circumstances. "Neither the law nor the Constitution compels an individual who is competent and able to take decisions, to disclose the reasons for refusing medical treatment nor is such a refusal subject to the supervisory control of an outside entity", Justice Chandrachud said.

He said, "Till now advanced medical directives did not have legal validity in our country".

"To decrease the misuse the court has said that making of living will be allowed only after getting certification from a medical authority that the patient's comatose state is irreversible", Rohan added.

Stocks Ensnare on Price Valuation: Applied Materials, Inc. (NASDAQ:AMAT)
It is positive, as 35 investors sold AWK shares while 185 reduced holdings. 115 funds opened positions while 384 raised stakes. According to their observations and findings, the stock could provide a high EPS of $1.15/share and a low EPS of $1.12/share.

We'll drop our tariffs if you drop yours — Trump to EU
In Sydney, Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull said there is no case for imposing tariffs on Australian steel. Tariffs would "seriously impact the normal order of global trade", the Commerce Ministry said.

Real on song as PSG falter again in Champions League
The defeat came a year after PSG went out at the same stage after losing 6-1 at Barcelona, having won the first leg 4-0.

"Today's is a landmark judgement because it comes at a time when medical science allows patients to be kept alive by artificial means and the hospitals to keep charging money", Vipul Mudgal, the head of main petitioner Common Cause, an advocacy group, told the BBC. Anumeha Jha, senior research analyst for the NGO, said that in 2016, the government's medical Bill addressed passive euthanasia as it was after Aruna Shanbaug's case.

Dr K K Aggarwal, vice -pesident of Confederation of Medical Associations in Asia and Oceania, and former IMA president, however, said strict guidelines should be put in place to ensure that there is no abuse of the "living will" by relatives of the terminally ill patient. "The safeguards that the court has built in should allay fears that some people may have", he said. A five-bench judge also defined the rule to implement the procedure in case there would be no living wills.

The 2015 death of 66-year-old nurse Aruna Shanbaug, who was raped and left in a vegetative state for 42 years, reignited India's national debate over euthanasia.

In January, the elderly couple had written a letter to President Ram Nath Kovind seeking permission for "active euthanasia".

In the absence of a law authorizing doctors to invoke an advance directive, they keep incurable patients on life support, he said. "SC has taken a good decision, we've hope now".

Related:

Comments

Latest news

Rahul Gandhi explains how he would have implemented demonetisation
Sonia Gandhi said she made a decision to take the political plunge when she saw the party was going through a very hard time. He said there is a challenge to India's idea of plurality and people's freedom is being challenged under the ruling regime.

Watch the trailer for Netflix's "Santa Clarita Diet" Season 2
As we get closer to the return of Santa Clarita Diet , Netflix has released a trailer for the upcoming second season of the dark comedy.

Conte calls for 'great resilience' against Barcelona - after narrow win over Palace
Palace has lost its last three Premier League games and hasn't won since a 1-0 victory over Burnley on January 13. Roy Hodgson and Antonio Conte were in the opposite dugouts when England played Italy in a friendly in March 2015.

The staggering number of people arrested for terror offences past year
Part of the increase in arrests was accounted for by large-scale police operations in the wake of the terror attacks. She also suggested that the police need to rethink their strategy when tackling suspected terrorists.

Turnbull Says Trump Promised Him Exemption on Metals Tariffs
Trump confirmed the exemption in an early Saturday morning call between the two leaders, Turnbull said. Turnbull went on to say, the USA has a large trade surplus with Australia.

Martin Shkreli sentenced to prison
His lawyers said he was a misunderstood eccentric who used unconventional means to make those same investors even wealthier. "Mr. Prosecutors had described the 34-year-old as a master manipulator who duped investors, and were calling for a 15-year sentence.

China says no to backdoor deals in new Silk Route
Asked about China's "sharp power", Mr Wang said, "It is time the China threat theory was laid to rest". China's global trade surplus widened to $33.7 billion from January's $20.3 billion.

Actor Nani Krishnarjuna Yuddham Movie Teaser OUT
The way Director Merlapaka Gandhi is trying to portray both the roles in different styles all in all. Apart from Nani , Krishnarjuna Yuddham has Anupama Parameshwaran and Ruksana Mir as the heroines.

Derrick Rose signs with T-Wolves
Thibodeau said he likes the versatility and mentioned how Minnesota played two point guards last season in Kris Dunn and Jones. He was with NY last season and started this season with Cleveland, but appeared in only 16 games with the Cavaliers.

Boston Celtics Announce Forward's Status After Scary Fall
The impact left him dazed, though he was ultimately able to get up and walk off the court with assistance. Brown is averaging 14.1 points and 5.2 rebounds per game through 61 contests this season.

IShares 20+ Year Treasury Bond (TLT) Declines 0.45% for Mar 9
Aggregate Bond Etf has a twelve month low of $1,920.01 and a twelve month high of $2,156.27. The firm acquired 1,932 shares of the company's stock, valued at approximately $211,000.

How Browns' trade for Tyrod Taylor will affect Giants on draft night
The Dolphins could match that offer, and if Landry leaves, they would receive two first-round picks from his new team. Taylor will have new receivers to throw to in newly acquired receiver Jarvis Landry , Josh Gordon and Corey Coleman .

Trump, Pence hold private meeting with NRA
He said lawmakers support expanding federal gun-purchase background checks to firearms sales conducted at gun shows and online. She said Trump's thinking on guns had not changed since Wednesday.

Impact of Steel and Aluminum Tariffs on Negotiations
Some form of retaliation appears likely from China, with which the USA traded more goods than any other country previous year . Elsewhere, Brazil and Britain were also quick to launch broadsides against the tariffs, which are worth billions of dollars.

Wasteful Huddersfield held by 10-man Swansea
However, Swansea held firm right until the very end and were able to claim an unlikely share of the spoils come the final whistle. Swansea City manager Carlos Carvalhal . "My players showed quality and character against a team that are hard to beat".

Other news